The Top Mistakes That Can Ruin Your Ohio Car Accident Case | Kisling, Nestico & Redick
Kisling, Nestico & Redick, LLC Hurt in a Car? Call KNR.
800-487-8669
800-487-8669
KNR 20th Anniversary logo

Car accidents are more than just an inconvenience. If you’ve been injured, the road to recovery often depends on getting financial compensation. But even small missteps can jeopardize your car accident claim or lawsuit, potentially reducing or eliminating the settlement you need to move forward.

Understanding the common car accident case mistakes people make and how to avoid them is critical. At Kisling, Nestico & Redick, our experienced Ohio car accident lawyers know how to protect your rights, avoid costly pitfalls, and fight for maximum compensation. We’re here to guide you through every step, making the auto accident claim process as smooth as possible.

If you or a loved one is hurt in an Ohio car accident and needs help, call 1-800-HURT-NOW today for a 100% free case evaluation. We never charge fees upfront; we only get paid when you receive compensation.

The Top 10 Mistakes That Jeopardize Ohio Car Accident Claims

The aftermath of any serious motor vehicle accident can leave you in physical pain, not to mention stressed, confused, and uncertain about what to do next. If the accident wasn’t your fault, you may be entitled to damages. However, securing that compensation often depends on avoiding key missteps that could harm your case. Even small errors can give insurance companies and defense attorneys the ammo they need to reduce or deny your claim.

Here are the most common mistakes our lawyers have encountered over the years, so you know what to look out for if you or a loved one are ever hurt in a car crash.

1. Delays in Medical Treatment Can Weaken Your Case

After a car accident, seeking medical attention right away is crucial, even if you feel fine or believe your injuries are minor. Delays in getting treated can make it harder to prove the accident caused your injuries, giving insurance companies a reason to deny or downplay your claim.

For example, if you experienced neck pain after a collision but didn’t see a doctor for two weeks. The insurer may claim your injuries were unrelated to the accident and deny compensation.

Our Tip

Always get a medical evaluation immediately after the accident and follow your doctor’s instructions to protect your case. Some injuries, like whiplash, concussions, or internal damage, may not show symptoms right away but can worsen over time if left untreated. A prompt medical evaluation establishes a clear link between the accident and your injuries, making it harder for insurance companies to argue that your condition was pre-existing or unrelated to the crash.

2. Don’t Skip Follow-Up Medical Care. It Undermines Your Claim

It’s not enough to visit a doctor once and expect your medical records to fully support your case. If you skip follow-up appointments or fail to follow your doctor’s treatment plan, such as physical therapy, medications, or surgery, the insurance company could argue that your injuries aren’t serious or that you’ve fully recovered.

If you miss physical therapy sessions or ignore a prescribed treatment, the insurer may use this as evidence to claim your injuries weren’t severe or that you didn’t take your recovery seriously.

Our Tip

Stay consistent with your medical care. Attend all follow-up appointments, follow your doctor’s recommendations, and keep detailed medical records to demonstrate that your injuries are legitimate and that you’re committed to recovery.

3. Admitting Fault or Apologizing Hurts Your Case

Emotions run high after car accidents, and many people apologize or admit fault without realizing the legal consequences. Under Ohio’s comparative negligence laws, admitting fault—even casually—could reduce what you’re eligible to receive or even disqualify you entirely if you’re found primarily at fault.

If you apologize to another driver or make statements suggesting you weren’t paying attention, these comments could be used to shift blame onto you, reducing your compensation.

Our Tip

When speaking to anyone at the scene, stick to the facts. Avoid discussing fault or giving opinions about what happened. Instead, exchange information and wait for the investigation to determine liability.

4. A Lack of Evidence Gives Insurers the Upper Hand

Strong evidence is critical to proving fault and establishing the full extent of your injuries and damages in any serious car accident lawsuit or personal injury claim. Unfortunately, many victims miss the opportunity to gather evidence at the scene, which can make it harder to build a strong case later.

Failing to take photos of the accident scene or get contact information from witnesses could give the insurance company room to dispute your version of events.

Our Tip

Take photos of vehicle damage, injuries, and road conditions immediately after the accident. If you’re too injured, ask someone at the scene for help. Make sure to get witness contact information and obtain a copy of the police report as soon as possible. Your attorney can also assist in gathering additional evidence, such as traffic camera footage, expert evaluations, and statements from witnesses.

5. Posting about the Crash on Social Can Backfire

Social media can be a major liability during a car accident case. Insurance companies and defense attorneys frequently monitor social media posts for anything that contradicts your claims, such as photos showing physical activity or comments that downplay your injuries.

For instance, the insurer may question your credibility if you post vacation photos after filing a car insurance injury claim. Engaging in activities that appear inconsistent with your reported injuries could lead them to argue that you’re exaggerating and reduce your settlement.

Our Tip

Avoid posting any details about the accident or your injuries on social media until the case is resolved. If possible, adjust your privacy settings and avoid posting altogether to prevent misunderstandings.

6. Making a Statement Without a Lawyer Is Risky

Insurance companies may contact you soon after the accident, hoping to get a recorded statement they can use against you. Without legal representation, you could accidentally say something that minimizes the severity of your injuries or admit partial blame.

If you described the accident to the insurer, casually mentioning that you “may have been driving a little fast.” The insurance company will likely use this statement to argue comparative negligence and reduce your compensation.

Our Tip

Never provide a statement or sign any documents without first consulting an attorney. Your lawyer can help ensure your words are carefully chosen and that you don’t unintentionally damage your case.

7. Accepting an Offer Without Guidance Can Cost You

Insurance companies are in the business of making money, which means they often try to settle claims quickly and for as little as possible. They may present you with a low-ball offer soon after the accident, knowing that many victims are stressed and eager for immediate financial relief. However, without understanding the long-term costs of your injuries—such as ongoing medical treatment, physical therapy, or lost income—you risk accepting far less than you need.

Suppose you receive an offer of $10,000 from the at-fault driver’s insurance. The adjuster may emphasize how this is such a “generous offer” and that you should accept it quickly because it “may not be available later.” They might even suggest they are doing you a favor by speeding up the process, so you don’t have to deal with a lengthy legal battle. Feeling overwhelmed by medical bills and time off work, you might accept without realizing that your injuries will require ongoing physical therapy and future surgeries, costing tens of thousands of dollars out of pocket.

Our Tip

Don’t rush to accept any settlement without consulting an experienced car accident attorney. Insurance companies often try to limit their liability, but an attorney can evaluate the true value of your claim, calculate your current and future damages, and negotiate for the maximum possible.

8. Missing the Statute of Limitations Could Bar Your Claim

In Ohio, you generally have two years from the date of the accident to file a personal injury lawsuit. Missing this legal deadline could mean permanently losing your right to recover any compensation, no matter how valid your claim may be.

If you wait too long, critical evidence may be lost, and witnesses may forget key details, making it even more difficult to prove your case, even if it’s filed late.

Our Tip

Work closely with an attorney to ensure all deadlines are met. Acting early gives your legal team time to gather evidence, secure witness statements, and build a strong case before any opportunities slip away.

9. Not Documenting Expenses Could Leave You with Less

Proper documentation of expenses after a car crash is key to demonstrating the full financial impact of your injuries and losses. Without accurate records of medical bills, lost wages, repair costs, and other expenses, insurers may argue that your damages are minimal and offer a lower settlement than you deserve.

Our Tip

Keep a detailed record of all accident-related expenses. This includes saving receipts, invoices, pay stubs for missed work, and even travel costs to medical appointments. Your attorney can use this documentation to demand maximum compensation.

10. Not Hiring an Experienced Attorney Could Be Your Most Costly Mistake

Car accident claims are rarely as straightforward as they seem. While it may be tempting to handle things independently, insurance companies are experts at minimizing or denying claims altogether. Without an experienced attorney advocating for you, you may not know how to push back against their tactics, which could leave you with significantly less compensation than you need to cover your recovery.

Let’s say you tried to handle negotiations alone after suffering a back injury in a collision. The insurance company may offer a quick settlement based on your initial medical bills, but they failed to include future treatments, physical therapy and lost wages from ongoing limitations. By the time you seek legal help, the statute of limitations might have passed, and it is too late to renegotiate. So, what seemed like a small oversight at the moment has turned into a financially devastating mistake.

Our Tip

Don’t underestimate the importance of hiring a skilled and experienced local car accident attorney. Failing to do so could result in you being responsible for many of the long-term costs that could have been covered. Consult with a car accident lawyer as soon as possible to protect your rights and secure the full compensation you deserve.

How an Attorney Can Help

An experienced car accident lawyer knows the legal process and how to maximize your claim by addressing current and future losses. Here’s how they can help:

  • Investigate: Gather evidence, such as accident reports, witness statements, and expert opinions, to establish fault.
  • File on Time: Ensure all deadlines, including Ohio’s statute of limitations, are met to preserve your right to compensation.
  • Calculate Damages: Accurately assess your immediate medical costs, future expenses, lost earning capacity, and pain and suffering.
  • Negotiate: Counter low-ball offers and pressure from insurers by negotiating for the full amount you deserve.
  • Represent You in Court: If a fair settlement isn’t reached, your attorney can represent you at trial and fight for your rights in front of a judge or jury.

Read What Does a Car Accident Lawyer Do?

Don’t Let Car Accident Mistakes Threaten Your Recovery – Call KNR.

At KNR, we understand a car accident’s lasting impact on your life—physically, emotionally, and financially. With 500+ years of combined legal experience and millions recovered for Ohio clients, our dedicated car accident lawyers know how to protect your rights and pursue maximum compensation.

Whether you’re facing uncooperative insurers or mounting expenses, we’ll guide you, ensuring your recovery is the priority. Call 1-800-HURT-NOW today for a free, no-obligation evaluation of your case. There’s No Fee Unless You Recover Compensation.