Ohio Attorney to Handle State Farm Car Accident Claim | KNR

On This Page

State Farm is at the top of the personal insurance market, and it leads the pack by quite a large margin. According to the Insurance Information Institute, the number one auto insurer in the U.S. has 10 percent of the market share, and more than $64 million in direct premiums written.

In Ohio, the company has earned praise for safety patrol vans that provide free roadside assistance along highways in Akron, Cincinnati, Cleveland, Columbus, and other cities. However, there are also plenty of complaints from policyholders and third parties when filing State Farm auto insurance accident claims.

Ohio’s insurance bad faith laws are intended to protect policyholders who seek compensation under rightful first-party claims. Insurers cannot take adverse action against their customers unless there is reasonable justification, but many still engage in misconduct. At Kisling, Nestico & Redick, our Ohio insurance claims lawyers have considerable experience going up against even the largest insurance companies in the United States.

To schedule a free consultation, contact us today at 1-800-HURT-NOW.

Historical Overview of State Farm

Founded in 1922 as a mutual auto insurance company owned by policyholders, State Farm expanded considerably over the next few decades. Auto insurance was, and still is, the primary focus. As of December 2017, more than half of the policies State Farm services in the U.S. and Canada are for auto coverage.

The company has experienced its share of criticism and controversy, especially as states take a more prominent role in enforcing insurance bad faith laws. When state insurance departments have not taken action, policyholders have filed civil lawsuits to enforce their rights. In a landmark early 2000s case, State Farm was forced to pay out $145 million in punitive damages for bad faith tactics in handling the claims of car accident victims.

The State Farm Auto Insurance Accident Claims Process in Ohio

At the outset, it’s important to understand how you file your claim after a car accident. If you’re an insured policyholder of State Farm, your claim is based upon your contract for coverage. You stand in the position of a first-party claimant. If you were injured in an auto collision by a driver who’s covered by State Farm, you file a third-party claim because you’re not in a contractual relationship with the company.

With this distinction in mind, there are certain steps you need to take to protect your interests, including:

  • Call the police to report the crash, as you’ll need an official account of the incident. However, dial 911 if there are injuries that require immediate medical attention.
  • Exchange contact information and insurance policy details for all motorists, and make a note if a driver is someone other than the insured owner of the vehicle.
  • Discuss the accident with anyone who may have witnessed it. These individuals may have important information related to fault if you’ll be filing a third-party claim.
  • Grab your cell phone and start taking pictures of the crash site, damage to vehicles, and physical conditions in the area.
  • Contact your State Farm representative if you’re a policyholder, regardless of fault. Third parties should contact their own insurance companies, then follow up as necessary regarding injuries and property damage.
A sunny day in Ohio with cars driving on a highway curving toward a city skyline with tall buildings, lush green trees, and a blue sky filled with white clouds.

We're Award-Winning & Highly-Skilled Attorneys

A badge with the text Best Law Firms, Ranked by Best Lawyers, United States, 2026 in black, red, and gray lettering on a shield-shaped background.
A gold and red badge with the text Trucking Top 10 Trial Lawyers and an image of the Lady Justice holding scales in the center.
White logo of The National Trial Lawyers, featuring a standing figure holding scales, with the text The National Trial Lawyers and Top 100 Trial Lawyers below.
A circular logo with a gold justice scale in the center, surrounded by a red border with the white text Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum.
Gold and black shield emblem with scales of justice, reading “Nation’s Premier NAOPIA Top Ten Attorney Personal Injury” on a gold ribbon with decorative stars at the bottom.
Circular gold and gray logo of The American Trial Lawyers Association, featuring a silhouette of Lady Justice holding scales, with ATLA in large white letters across the center.
Red hexagon with large white letters AV in the center. Faint white text underneath reads PREEMINENT, but the smaller text below is blurry and difficult to read.
White text on a light gray background reads Super Lawyers in large, bold letters.
A circular logo with a gold border featuring the image of Lady Justice holding scales and a sword in the center, surrounded by blue bands with the words The National Trial Lawyers.
Circular logo with a gold scale of justice in the center on a red background. The outer black ring contains the words Million Dollar Advocates Forum in white, all capital letters.

How State Farm Auto Insurance Accident Claims Work

When you’re filing as a policyholder, you have certain rights based upon your contractual relationship with State Farm. Knowing the company’s record for treatment of its own customers, it’s smart to work with an Ohio insurance claims lawyer to ensure State Farm upholds its end of the bargain. Fault in the accident will not be an issue. Typically, you’re filing as a first party when you were responsible for the crash, or if the incident only caused damage to your vehicle.

The terms of your policy dictate what you can recover, but potential State Farm claims may include:

Personal Injury Protection

If you carry PIP, you can recover a percentage of your medical bills and lost wages after paying your deductible.

Collision Coverage

The holder of your car loan may require you to carry collision, but it’s not mandatory under Ohio law. This coverage pays for property damage to your vehicle in the event of an auto crash.

Comprehensive Coverage

While this option is expensive, it will reimburse you if your vehicle suffers damage from an incident other than a traffic-related crash.

Uninsured and Uninsured Motorist Claims

Though Ohio requires motorists to carry certain minimum levels of auto insurance, some don’t follow the law. Other drivers might not have enough insurance to cover your losses. In both cases, you can file a claim as a first party if you add this option to your policy.

As a third-party claimant with injuries, property damage, or both, your rights are different as compared to a State Farm policyholder. You should reach out to a personal injury attorney for help with recovering compensation for medical bills, lost income, and pain and suffering.

An Ohio Insurance Claims Lawyer Can Help with Your Claim

If you’re a policyholder running into roadblocks in filing State Farm auto insurance accident claims, please contact Kisling, Nestico & Redick to set up a free consultation about your situation. We can investigate potential misconduct by the company and advise you on your legal options. You can reach our Ohio insurance bad faith lawyers by calling 1-800-HURT-NOW, or by visiting us online.

Five professionally dressed people sit around a conference table, using laptops and reviewing documents. Large windows and greenery are visible in the background, suggesting a modern office setting.

What Makes KNR Special?

Serving Ohio for More than 20 Years

Since our inception in 2005, Kisling, Nestico & Redick has been dedicated to helping personal injury victims fight for the compensation they deserve after an accident affects their way of life. We have helped more than 10,000 people, and we’re ready to keep fighting for Ohioans and anyone who deserves compensation for their personal injury claims.

Free Consultations // Available 24/7 // No Recovery, No Fee

Contact KNR

Contact KNR Now to Start Your Case

Name(Required)

**Submitting a case description or engaging in a chat does not create an attorney-client relationship. But everything you tell us remains confidential, even if you don’t become a client of KNR. Please click the ‘Submit’ button below to confirm your submission.